Skip to main content
Prosciutto Hero

Hoagies in Sunset Park, Brooklyn

Explore the hoagies menu at The Astarita in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY, available for pickup to satisfy every craving.

Order online

Meet The Astarita

The Astarita in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY offers a satisfying hoagies lineup packed with classic hero options worth exploring any day of the week.

From the #1 Prosciutto Hero to the hearty #2 Meatball Hero and the fresh #4 Caprese Hero, there is a hoagie here to match every appetite and mood.

Visit The Astarita in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY and enjoy your hoagies your way — whether you choose dine-in, pickup, or delivery for added convenience.

Hoagies to Try

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular hoagies options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Prosciutto Hero — This sandwich features prosciutto, an Italian cured ham, in a hero-style long roll for straightforward deli flavor.
  • Meatball Hero — This hero is a meatball sandwich served in a hoagie roll, typically with tomato sauce.
Do you offer delivery and takeout?
Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for hoagies throughout the Sunset Park, Brooklyn area. Order your hoagies online for convenient pickup or delivery.
Do you take reservations?
Yes! We accept reservations through Resy. You can easily reserve a table online by selecting your preferred date, time, and party size.