Pizza, pasta, meatball heroes, and eggplant dishes anchor Italian food at The Astarita in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, available for pickup.
Order onlineChicken Parm Plate
$29.12
A chicken cutlet topped in the Italian-style Parmesan preparation.
“Amazing food, service and vibe. Owner is very nice and has an authentic neopolitan wood burning stove that's makes the crispiest crust that side of Brooklyn. Highly recommend great prices as well!!”
Eggplant Rollatini
$27.04
Sliced eggplant rolled around a savory filling in an Italian starter.
“I had a wonderful experience here!! The food is delicious and authentic. The service was kind and attentive. I especially loved the eggplant and the meatballs!! I will definitely be back and highly recommend!”
Homemade Meatballs
$22.80
Meatballs with tomato sauce, Parmigiano, and fresh ricotta.
“One of my favorite pizza spots! I love the Mr. William pizza and homemade meatballs. The service here is always so friendly, kind, and fast. There is ample seating inside and the ambiance is very peaceful. The outdoor seating is perfect, I can't wait until it's warm enough again to enjoy a slice under the fairy lights!”
Antipasto
$24.96
An antipasto of mozzarella, tomatoes, olives, peppers, and prosciutto.
“Absolutely delicious food! We split the antipasto appetizer, the greenwood veggie pizza, the homemade tiramisu, and had a couple of beers and espressos. Everything was so tasty and good portions. Service was fantastic! Friendly, attentive staff. The vibe and atmosphere was perfect for our date night!”
New York Style
$27.04
New York-style pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, olive oil, and basil.
“Their Classic NY Pizza is DYNAMITE!!! Honestly my wife is starting to get on me about having it too often! The people are so nice and friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and they have a small, but very nice wine list. I ‘accidentally’ get there early for pick up so I can enjoy a glass of red while waiting! Wish I could give six stars!!”
Mr. William Pizza
$31.20
Tomato-sauce pizza with mozzarella, pepperoni, and hot honey.
“The best eggplant parm/eggplant rollatini ever. The sauce is so fresh and authentic and they add lots of cheese and ricotta. Also, the pizza is amazing and fresh I always get the Mr. Williams pizza.”
The Astarita Pizza
$35.36
Margherita-style pizza finished with fresh ricotta cheese.
“I can not even begin to explain how amazing this place is! The atmosphere is so laid back and relaxing, the staff is so friendly and accomodating. And the food.....OMG. The pizza is so fresh and crispy. And the dessert pizza.....beyond amazing. I would highly recommend this gem of a restaurant to everyone!!! I will definitely be back soon!!”
Greenwood Vegetable Pizza
$39.52
Tomato pizza with mushrooms, peppers, garlic, shallots, and artichokes.
“AMAZING pizza (so good I forgot to take a photo). We got the Capriccioso and the Greenwood Vegetable and two salads. Nice crispy thin crust, great sauce, fresh toppings. 12/10”
Calzone
$28.80
Folded pizza dough baked around a savory filling.
“The Mr. William and the calzone are a must try!”
Rigattoni w/ Vodka Sauce
$22.88
Rigatoni in creamy pink vodka sauce with grated Parmesan.
“Everything was wonderful. I recommend the vodka sauce. Pizza was perfection. All flavors blended beautifully with fresh ingredients. Our server was very friendly and not fake. Love the Tuscan style vibe of the pizza shop. 100% recommended!!”
Pesto Pasta
$20.80
Spinach fusilli with pesto, grated Parmigiano Reggiano, and ricotta.
“This is such a wonderful spot for a local family dinner date year round - cozy in winter and a sunny patio in summer. Great atmosphere, excellent food, and really welcoming warm staff, and an owner who goes above to take care of you. A real neighborhood gem! Love the Seasonal Salad, the Mr. William pizza, and our 5 year old inhales the Pesto Pasta every time. If you still have room you will not regret treating yourself to the Miss Sofia Nutella dessert pizza!”
Meatball Hero
$16.64
A meatball sandwich served on a long Italian-style hero roll.
“Beautiful place and authentic italian pizza. We love it and come often.”
Prosciutto Hero
$20.80
Prosciutto hero sandwich with cured ham in a long sandwich roll.
Housemade Tiramisu
$10.40
Tiramisu layers coffee-soaked ladyfingers with mascarpone cream and cocoa.
“Delicious crispy pizza and a lovely homemade tiramisu. Cute atmosphere and very friendly service, will definitely be back to try more!”
Miss Sofia
$15.60+
Sweet pizza with Nutella, strawberries, bananas, and mascarpone cream.
“The laid back atmosphere made it easy and comfortable for dining with our kids, who are already asking when are we going back?! The pizza was absolutely delicious. Great sauce with a light and airy crust, you won't feel bad that you had four slices! The whipped marscapone on the Nutella pizza helped to make it the best I'd ever had. I will absolutely be going back very soon!”
The Astarita serves Italian food spanning tomato-sauced pizzas, meatball heroes, eggplant dishes, and linguini. You can also have pizza topped with artichoke hearts, portobello mushrooms, and shallots.
Pizza Bianco pairs fresh mozzarella with ricotta; Rigattoni W/ Vodka Sauce has creamy pink sauce and grated Parmesan. Truffle Oil Pizza combines smoked scamorza, scallions, pancetta, and truffle oil.
Visit us in Sunset Park, Brooklyn for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Miss Sofia tops pizza with Nutella, strawberries, bananas, powdered sugar, and mascarpone whipped cream, in 12- or 16-inch sizes.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
