Pizza in Sunset Park, Brooklyn

“Great spot for a lowkey, intimate birthday dinner with family or a casual bite with friends! The seasonal salad is a must. The arugula pizza was a group favorite as well. Thank you to Tina and team for helping host our group of 18– so welcoming, attentive and yum. Throwback playlist was a plus.”

“I can not even begin to explain how amazing this place is! The atmosphere is so laid back and relaxing, the staff is so friendly and accomodating. And the food.....OMG. The pizza is so fresh and crispy. And the dessert pizza.....beyond amazing. I would highly recommend this gem of a restaurant to everyone!!! I will definitely be back soon!!”

“I am no spring chicken and have a long history of loving pizza. The pizza I had last night was the BEST pizza I have ever had, ever. The crust is thin but not dry. The ingredients are fresh and delicious. We had the four seasons pizza which was amazing. The arugula salad with mushrooms was great as well. Service was great, and we wish Tina much success with her great restaurant”

“Everything was perfection! The seasonal salad was amazing! Just when I should be full, the four seasons pizza came to our table! I would eat this during any season for sure! (I finally said enough after 3 slices) Quaint, warm and friendly!!!! Can’t wait to go back!”

“Absolutely delicious food! We split the antipasto appetizer, the greenwood veggie pizza, the homemade tiramisu, and had a couple of beers and espressos. Everything was so tasty and good portions. Service was fantastic! Friendly, attentive staff. The vibe and atmosphere was perfect for our date night!”

“Delicious, homemade, sweet little restaurant in the perfect spot. Don’t miss out on this scrumptious pizza!”

“The best eggplant parm/eggplant rollatini ever. The sauce is so fresh and authentic and they add lots of cheese and ricotta. Also, the pizza is amazing and fresh I always get the Mr. Williams pizza.”

“Stumbled upon this pizza place after a stroll through Greenwood. The staff was attentive, even though we were there during off hours and the pizza was fantastic! We ordered the Mr. William and would recommend to anyone visiting Brooklyn!”

“Best pizza in Brooklyn! Cool space and very friendly staff. A neighborhood gem that's bound to become a destination spot. Our favorite pies are the Magherita and Mr. William.”

“Great Pizza and great service.”

“Their Classic NY Pizza is DYNAMITE!!! Honestly my wife is starting to get on me about having it too often! The people are so nice and friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and they have a small, but very nice wine list. I ‘accidentally’ get there early for pick up so I can enjoy a glass of red while waiting! Wish I could give six stars!!”

“Ordered for pick up a NY style pizza with prosciutto.. well cooked! Just perfect! Thank you..!”

“My first time at The Astarita! What a cute little place. The atmosphere was so friendly and the service was impeccable. We tried the meatball as an appetizer! 👍🏽 Delish!! We tried the “Mr. William” pizza and “Pizza Bianco” for dinner. I never knew honey on pizza was even thing 👌🏽. Sooo good! And that Ricotta 🤤. They even have dessert, so to finish we had the “Miss Sofia” for Dessert! You have got to try it!! 🫶🏼This place overall is an absolute must try!! If you are in the area check it out. 🤌🏽🇮🇹🍕🍷#Foodcoma #Brooklyn #TheAstarita”

“This place is a true neighborhood gem. A huge group of us came for a meal after my dad's funeral service at Greenwood Cemetery, and everything was so perfect. The staff were so kind and accommodating, and the food was incredible. Everyone raved about the classic NY pie and the white pie. Can't wait to visit again (under more joyful circumstances)!”

“AMAZING pizza (so good I forgot to take a photo). We got the Capriccioso and the Greenwood Vegetable and two salads. Nice crispy thin crust, great sauce, fresh toppings. 12/10”

“The pizza is absolutely delicious, quaint lovely atmosphere..great service.”

“Quattro Formaggi is absolutely the best add sausage and shallots and you will be addicted 🍕”

“Really delicious pizza!”

“Love this wonderful neighborhood restaurant! We were in town this past week visiting our kids and had a delightful time. Service was outstanding too We ordered the meatballs, Rose pizza and Caesar salad and everything was delicious! Often Caesar salads have too much dressing for my taste but this one was utter perfection. We will be returning soon, and we are all dying to try the Nutella pizza!”

“Best pizza in the area”

“Top tier pizza, this neighborhood gem is hands down the best in the area. The Mr. Williams pizza did not disappoint.”

“The best pizza it been trying 😋”

“Really solid little sit-down pizza spot, hidden off the beaten path. The pizzas are perfection, and the charming interior feels like a fancy night out, never loud or crowded. I love bringing friends here when we're in the area. They're always blown away and ask 'how did you find this??' Truly a hidden gem.”

“Stopped by this place because I live in the neighborhood and thought it was great! BYOB which is awesome and pizzas very tasty and well-priced. Split a pizza and a salad between two people and was the perfect amount of food. Great spot for a cheap date!”