Pizza in Sunset Park, Brooklyn

“Great spot for a lowkey, intimate birthday dinner with family or a casual bite with friends! The seasonal salad is a must. The arugula pizza was a group favorite as well. Thank you to Tina and team for helping host our group of 18– so welcoming, attentive and yum. Throwback playlist was a plus.”

“Excellent pizza, one of the best in the area. Great service and a nice relaxed ambiance in the place as well.”

“Such a gem in the neighborhood if you like a really crispy crust, proper sauce and high quality ingredients! I highly recommend sausage pizza and mushroom with ricotta pizza. Delicious. Shared a pizza among 2 adults, 2 kids. Perfect size.”

“Top 5 pizza in Brooklyn!”

“Absolutely delicious food! We split the antipasto appetizer, the greenwood veggie pizza, the homemade tiramisu, and had a couple of beers and espressos. Everything was so tasty and good portions. Service was fantastic! Friendly, attentive staff. The vibe and atmosphere was perfect for our date night!”

“Consistently delicious and wholesome pizza. Nice staff, cozy location.”

“One of my favorite pizza spots! I love the Mr. William pizza and homemade meatballs. The service here is always so friendly, kind, and fast. There is ample seating inside and the ambiance is very peaceful. The outdoor seating is perfect, I can't wait until it's warm enough again to enjoy a slice under the fairy lights!”

“Top tier pizza, this neighborhood gem is hands down the best in the area. The Mr. Williams pizza did not disappoint.”

“Their Classic NY Pizza is DYNAMITE!!! Honestly my wife is starting to get on me about having it too often! The people are so nice and friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and they have a small, but very nice wine list. I ‘accidentally’ get there early for pick up so I can enjoy a glass of red while waiting! Wish I could give six stars!!”

“Really enjoyed it. Top-tier pizza, thoughtful staff, attention to detail, excellent atmosphere. Excellent.”

“Just what we were looking for. I got the New York pizza with sausage and red peppers, it was excellent as well as the desserts. Very glad we were able to find this great place.”

“Salad to start was excellent and generously portioned. Then came the pizza— delicious. Our new favorite neighborhood restaurant. Warm atmosphere and service on a chilly evening.”

“This place is a true neighborhood gem. A huge group of us came for a meal after my dad's funeral service at Greenwood Cemetery, and everything was so perfect. The staff were so kind and accommodating, and the food was incredible. Everyone raved about the classic NY pie and the white pie. Can't wait to visit again (under more joyful circumstances)!”

“Best pizza I've ever had.”

“AMAZING pizza (so good I forgot to take a photo). We got the Capriccioso and the Greenwood Vegetable and two salads. Nice crispy thin crust, great sauce, fresh toppings. 12/10”

“Consistently Amazing crispy thin crust pizza in a charming low key pizza restaurant across from Greenwood!! Salads are so fresh , large and delicious too!! Also they serve 3 different Other Half beers!!”

“Mama Mia 🤌 I'm a truck driver, and I've tried many different places throughout every state, but I've never had pizza like this place. Its pizzas are unmatched, the best I've had. I wish the chef the best of health to live to 100. Pizza #1✔️”

“Amazing night out with incredible pizza and wonderful service for my first night out after an operation! Definitely coming back!!”

“Whole pies have gotten to be expensive all around recently, but if you're going to spend the money, it's worth it here. We ordered the Rose and it was truly one of the best pizzas we've had in ages. My Brooklyn-born partner exclaimed "wow, this is excellent!", and he doesn't like much 😭.”

“Always a great dinner at The Astarita. Delicious and big salads, pastas, and pies! A neighborhood gem!”

“Love their flavorful thin-crust pies!”

“Group of 7 after bowling nearby. The pizza toppings were tasty and not overwhelming, and the pizza was cooked to perfection - which in my view includes a little char on the crust. The service was prompt and friendly with a family vibe. We are so glad we happened on this place and will definitely be back!”

“This place is a hidden gem. I'm not sure why it wasn't more packed. The pizza was delicious. It was a perfectly crispy crust and didn't get soggy with all the toppings that we ordered. The cheese was absolutely top quality as well. This is one of the best pizza places I've been to and I make it a point to try a lot. I'd love to go back and just get the plain pizza. I'm sure it's perfect.”

“Excellent food and ambiance along with a terrific staff. Pizza is unbelievable, light & airy.”